Несносный наблюдатель (cema) wrote,
Несносный наблюдатель

Devid Gelernter in the Weekly Standard

The Roots of European Appeasement.


No one defends British appeasement of Hitler; everyone agrees that Churchill was right to oppose it from the start. No one criticizes British appeasement of Gandhi and the Congress party in India (Gandhi and Hitler stand at opposite ends of the moral spectrum, but there is a clear analogy between British attitudes towards the two of them); everyone agrees that Churchill was wrong to oppose it from the start. Hitlerite Germany was the exception. India proved to be the rule.


[...] well-placed American Jews in newspapers, TV, and radio have played in slanting the news against Israel. For the most part these seem to be well-meaning people who care so deeply about right and wrong, they have no time to distinguish between true and false.


Obviously the analogy between Poland and Israel is rough. Poland was submerged for 123 years, Israel for nearly two millennia. But the similarities are obvious, too. Lots of Arabs moved to Israel during the years when no Jewish state existed. Lots of Germans moved to Poland. But Poles and Jews maintained an unbroken presence in their homelands. The idea that a Pole returning to Poland is a "colonist" is idiotic; a Jew returning to Israel is no "colonist" either. Nor does the fact of a large Polish diaspora in America make Poland's existence any less necessary. Nor does the Jewish diaspora make Israel less necessary.

  • про кружку

    Прошла от дома ты до лагерного сбора, Судьба свела нас за обеденным столом. И вот теперь уже почти неделя скоро, Как неразлучные товарищи живем с…

  • О, как согласно струны etc

    Странно, во всём таком большом интернете всего одна копия текста. Дмитрий Киммельфельд. О, как согласно струны пели, Созвучно вам, созвучно мне.…

  • Дом, дом, дом

    А вот Кинеры: Горный приют Стихи Михаила Кинера, Музыка Бориса Кинера Дон - Дум-дум-дон... - Медным ртом древней башни - Дом, где твой дом?…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.